Why Madara is a Better Villain than Kaguya in Naruto

Naruto is one of the most popular and influential manga and anime series of all time. It has a rich and complex story that spans over 700 chapters and 500 episodes. One of the main aspects of the story is the conflict between the heroes and the villains, who have different motivations and ideologies. Among the many villains that Naruto and his friends have faced, two of them stand out as the most powerful and the most controversial: Madara Uchiha and Kaguya Otsutsuki.

The Build-Up of Madara and Kaguya

One of the main differences between Madara and Kaguya is the amount of build-up they have in the story. Madara is introduced very early in the series, as the legendary leader of the Uchiha clan and the rival of Hashirama Senju, the first Hokage. He is mentioned several times throughout the story, as the mastermind behind the Akatsuki, the Fourth Great Ninja War, and the revival of the Ten-Tails. He is also the ancestor of Sasuke Uchiha, Naruto’s best friend and rival, and the reincarnation of Indra Otsutsuki, the son of Hagoromo Otsutsuki, the Sage of Six Paths.
Madara’s build-up is gradual and consistent, as he is revealed to be more and more involved in the events of the story. He is also shown to be a formidable opponent, who can fight against multiple Kage, the five strongest ninja in the world, at the same time. He has a variety of abilities, such as the Sharingan, the Rinnegan, the Mangekyo Sharingan, the Eternal Mangekyo Sharingan, the Wood Release, the Six Paths Senjutsu, and the Limbo. He is also charismatic, cunning, and confident, as he manipulates and challenges his enemies with his words and actions.
Kaguya, on the other hand, is introduced very late in the story, as the mother of Hagoromo and Hamura Otsutsuki, and the origin of chakra. She is barely mentioned before her appearance, and her backstory is only explained by Hagoromo, who appears as a spirit to Naruto and Sasuke. She is revealed to be the true final villain of the series, who was sealed by her sons long ago, and who manipulated Madara and Black Zetsu to free her from her prison. She is also shown to be extremely powerful, as she can create and manipulate dimensions, use all the nature transformations, and absorb any chakra.
Kaguya’s build-up is sudden and rushed, as she is brought into the story without much foreshadowing or explanation. She is also shown to be a bland and boring opponent, who does not have any personality, motivation, or dialogue. She only acts as a mindless and emotionless threat, who wants to reclaim all the chakra in the world for herself. She does not have any connection or interaction with the main characters, and she does not pose any moral or ideological challenge to them.


The Motivation of Madara and Kaguya

Another difference between Madara and Kaguya is the reason why they want to create a new world order. Madara has a complex and tragic motivation, that stems from his experiences and his worldview. He was born in a time of constant war and violence, where he lost his brothers and his friends. He tried to end the cycle of hatred by forming an alliance with Hashirama, but he was betrayed by his own clan and his former friend. He witnessed the suffering and the corruption of the ninja world, and he became disillusioned and cynical.
Madara’s motivation is to create a world of peace and harmony, where everyone can live happily and freely. He believes that the only way to achieve this is by using the Infinite Tsukuyomi, which will erase the reality and replace it with a dream. He thinks that the current world is a nightmare, and that people are better off living in a fantasy. He also wants to fulfill his promise to his childhood friend, Izuna Uchiha, who died in his arms, and who asked him to protect their clan and their ideals.
Kaguya, on the other hand, has a simple and selfish motivation, that does not have any depth or nuance. She was originally a princess from another world, who came to Earth with a mission to harvest the God Tree, a giant plant that produces chakra. She fell in love with a human, and gave birth to two sons, who inherited her chakra. She became greedy and paranoid, and feared that her sons would take her chakra away from her. She merged with the God Tree, and became the Ten-Tails, a monstrous beast that attacked her sons and the world.
Kaguya’s motivation is to reclaim all the chakra that she considers to be hers, and to destroy anyone who opposes her. She does not care about the well-being or the happiness of anyone else, and she does not have any vision or goal for the new world. She only acts on her primal instincts, and she does not have any reason or logic behind her actions. She also does not have any attachment or emotion for her sons, and she does not acknowledge them as her family.

The Role of Madara and Kaguya in the Story

The final difference between Madara and Kaguya is the impact and the significance they have in the story. Madara is a major and influential character, who has a direct and indirect role in the development and the growth of the main characters and the plot. He is the catalyst and the antagonist of the main conflict, the Fourth Great Ninja War, which involves all the nations and the characters of the series. He is also the mentor and the enemy of Obito Uchiha, one of the main villains and the former friend of Kakashi Hatake, Naruto’s teacher. He is also the inspiration and the rival of Sasuke Uchiha, who follows his footsteps and his ideology, before changing his mind and joining Naruto.
Madara’s role is to challenge and test the main characters, both physically and mentally. He represents the dark side of the ninja world, the cycle of hatred, and the curse of the Uchiha. He also represents the opposite of Naruto’s ideals, the will of fire, and the power of friendship. He forces the main characters to question their beliefs, their goals, and their actions. He also pushes them to surpass their limits, to unlock new powers, and to cooperate with each other. He is the final obstacle and the ultimate enemy that the main characters have to overcome, to prove themselves and to save the world.
Kaguya, on the other hand, is a minor and irrelevant character, who does not have any connection or relation with the main characters or the plot. She is a deus ex machina and a plot device, who is introduced to end the story and to resolve the problem of Madara’s power. She is not involved in the main conflict, the Fourth Great Ninja War, and she does not have any influence or effect on the other characters or events of the series. She is also not related or linked to any of the main characters, and she does not have any personal or emotional stake in the outcome of the story.
Kaguya’s role is to be defeated and sealed by the main characters, with the help of Hagoromo and the other tailed beasts. She does not challenge or test the main characters, neither physically nor mentally. She does not represent anything meaningful or symbolic, and she does not have any theme or message. She does not force the main characters to change or grow, to learn or discover, or to cooperate or communicate. She is the final boss and the ultimate threat that the main characters have to face, but not to prove themselves or to save the world, but to end the story and to move on.


In conclusion, Madara is a better villain than Kaguya in Naruto, because he has more build-up, more motivation, and more role in the story. He is a complex and interesting character, who has a history and a personality, who has a vision and a goal, and who has a connection and a conflict with the main characters. He is a memorable and iconic villain, who has left a mark and a legacy in the series and in the fandom. Kaguya, on the other hand, is a simple and boring character, who does not have any backstory or character, who does not have any reason or logic, and who does not have any relation or impact on the main characters. She is a forgettable and disappointing villain, who has been added and removed from the series and from the fandom.






Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *